Hoka vs On Cloud vs Brooks: 6 Differences You Need To check

Hoka, On Cloud, and Brooks are exceptional on their own. But when it comes to comparison, choosing one over the other can be difficult. Are you going through the same confusion?

If so, we’ve got you covered. Hoka shoes excel in cushioning, and On Clouds perform the best. Similarly, Brooks shoes are famous for their excellent support. 

We already have a detailed comparison between hoka vs on cloud and hoka vs brooks. But depending on your needs and preferences, your shoe choices will change. So, if you want to know which shoes will be best for you among the three, we have a whole review ready for you. In this review, we will dive into the technologies used in all three shoe brands. Along with customer reviews, we will share our personal experience with these shoes.

Hoka vs On Cloud vs Brooks: 6 Differences To Know

Hoka vs On Cloud vs Brooks: 6 Differences You Need To check

1. Cushioning and Support Technology

Hoka and On running shoes are great in terms of cushioning. On the other hand, Brooks has amazing support and stability mechanisms.

Hoka’s statement “designed to drive runners forward” has definitely come up to its claim. The unique rocker sole design offers smooth heel-to-toe transitions. 

The curved design of the Meta-Rocker sole mimics the natural running gait. It also prevents the feet from landing flat on the ground while running. The less heel-to-toe drop is another bonus for support and comfort.

We love the ProFly X foam due to its soft and responsive feel. The foam is placed in the forefoot and heel in such a way that it pushes you forward while offering comfort. Runners also feel that the cushioning prevents leg fatigue, which makes it great for recovery runs.

On cloud running shoes are known as “energy-saving” shoes due to their CloudTec and Speedboard technology. The curved and firm Speedboard plate offers proprioception and stability. It can adapt to different running styles to give the sensation of running on clouds. Runners also state that the shoes reduce strain on the foot and have great shock-absorbing capabilities.

The CloudTec technology is one of a kind. The hollow CloudTec pods are great for providing a springy feel that propels forward movement. Also, the Helion super foam is a great feature that provides the feel you want. It is a mixture of EVA and OBC foams. The foam is extremely lightweight and responsive, which saves energy while running.

Brooks shoes come with high-quality DNA LOFT cushioning. This foam is a combination of rubber, EVA foam, and nitrogen. Due to this, the cushioning is soft and gives a resilient performance. Runners often love the springy feel and energy return of these shoes. Thanks to its cushioning.

The GuideRails support technology is a subtle way to prevent pronation. Brooks has placed foam on the inside of the feet. This prevents the feet from rolling inwards while running. Thus, runners get a stable performance.

2. Weight, Drop, and General Fit

Beyond cushioning, here’s how Hoka, On, and Brooks running shoes compare in terms of weight, heel drop, foot shape, and overall fit.

The collection of Hoka has lightweight as well as heavy shoes. For example, Clifton 9 weighs around 8.7 oz. in men’s range,and 7.3 oz. in women’s. Also, the heel-to-toe drop of most Hoka shoes is 4-5mm, with some having a drop of 6mm. Compared to others, this drop is fine.

Similarly, On running shoes weigh 9-10 oz. in the men’s category on average. Women’s shoes weigh around 7-8 oz. Most On Clouds have a heel-to-toe drop of 9mm, which is higher than Hoka.

Brooks running shoes weigh 9-10 oz. on average. Thus, the weight of all three running shoes is somehow comparable, with most Hokas being slightly heavier. The heel-to-toe drop of Brooks shoes is 8-10mm. Thus, Hokas have the least heel-to-toe drop for smooth transitions.

The overall fit of Hoka and On running shoes is quite similar. Most users of Hoka and On say that the shoes fit snugly. The narrow fit of Hoka shoes is due to their maximum cushioning. Most Hoka shoes are not available in wide sizes. Brooks shoes have a larger toe box and also come in wider sizes for big feet.

3. Price

While brands differ in technology and fit, price can also be a key factor in choosing between Hoka vs On vs Brooks. Here’s an overview of how their pricing stacks up.

Runners often consider Hoka shoes expensive. Their prices differ depending on the type of shoes and technology. However, most Hoka shoes range between $100 and $180. Some cheaper versions may cost less than $50, while expensive ones cost more than $200. Tennine running shoes are a great example of expensive yet functional shoes.

The average price of On running shoes is $130-$170, while that of Brooks is $100-$150. Brooks Adrenaline GTS 22 are comfortable running shoes at a reasonable price. 

Also, Cloudvista running shoes by On are great for trail running. The cost of these shoes is $150.

While Hoka running shoes are famous for being expensive, we noticed that On and Brooks are in line with Hoka shoes in terms of price. The most expensive models of these shoes also come with better materials and smooth performance. Thus, if you want the best performance on all terrains, you might have to budget up to enjoy multiple features.

Still, you can find better shoes that fit your purpose at an affordable cost.

4. Reviews and Ratings: What Real Runners are Saying

Curious what fellow runners think of Hoka, On, and Brooks? Let’s check out excerpts from real shoe reviews that highlight the brands’ advantages and drawbacks.

When it comes to Hoka, we know that the cushioning is what runners will love the most. According to a few runners, “The exaggerated cushioning is a dream for recovery runs!”

In one review, a runner tested the Hoka Challenger 7 and was pretty impressed by it. However, the tester still thought that Speedgoat 5 could be a better performer.

Some runners were of the view that Hoka shoes are great for marathons and trail running. As one runner states, “Great for ultramarathons, but too bulky for faster workouts.”

Runners also have some great reviews about On cloud running shoes: “The CloudTec pods combine cushion and bounce – feels amazing at faster paces!” 

One tester of On Cloudboom Echo 3 said that these shoes are ideal for running faster and covering shorter distances. However, these didn’t give a better feel when running slowly on your own. Another user said, “Runs a bit firm for my liking on longer distances.”

The cushioning and support of Brooks running shoes have also received a lot of liking from customers. One user said, “The DNA LOFT foam provides the perfect balance of softness and responsiveness.”

Some Brooks Ghost 14 texters liked the comfortable and smooth ride. But, they faced minor sizing issues too. Similarly, another reviewer said, “Some models like the Ghost feel a bit narrow, especially in the toe box.”

5. Getting the Right Fit: Hoka, On, and Brooks Sizing Tips

To get your perfect fit in Hoka, On, or Brooks, keep these key sizing tips in mind.

Hoka shoes are designed in a way that they fit true to size. However, these shoes have a snug fit and a smaller toe box. Therefore, you should size up if you find the pairs half a size bigger. For runners with narrow feet, Hoka will stay just right. According to my experience, they run true to size. But runners with wide feet should opt for a bigger size. Luckily, Hoka shoes are also available in wide sizes.

According to most runner reviews, On cloud running shoes are also true to size. However, the official website of the company recommends going half a size up. Although the shoes don’t have a wide toe box, they still give a snug fit.

While Brooks running shoes are famous for having large toe boxes, most runners say they run small. That is why it is better to order a size larger than your regular shoes in Brooks’ version. 

Luckily, Brooks shoes are also available in wide and extra-wide sizes. Combined with the roomy toe box, wide sizes can be an ideal fit for runners with big feet.

However, remember that the right fit of your running shoes will depend on your feet size and shape. The break-in period also counts. Both Hoka and Brooks running shoes will take a few weeks to break in. Some Hoka shoes will break in after a few days.

The best choice is to visit a specialty store to buy a fresh pair of shoes. You can ask them to get your shoes properly fitted. A snug fit is great because when the shoes break in, they will expand a bit to give a more comfy feel.

brooks glycerin 20

6. Hoka vs On Cloud vs Brooks for standing all day

Hoka, On Cloud, and Brooks can be great for people who stand all day. Hoka models are famous for their maximum cushioning. On Clouds specialize in lightweight cushioning. On the other hand, Brooks shoes have great support and stability.

You can opt for Hoka running shoes if you want a plush feel while standing all day. The soft cushioning covers the foot and prevents overpronation. The less heel-to-toe drop also keeps you in contact with the ground while running.

On Clouds are great for running and getting a bouncy feel. But, they might lag in stability. The shoes have lightweight cushioning and an overall snug fit. According to the test, these shoes are great for running.

However, Brooks shoes can be a great choice if you want to stand all day. These shoes have great stability mechanisms that prevent overpronation. Also, the cushioning is just right to keep your feet comfortable the whole day.

Caring for Your Hoka, On, or Brooks Shoes

Once you’ve chosen your shoes, extend your life with proper care between runs.

Switching between shoes, air drying overnight, using insoles, and replacing shoes regularly are great ideas. Let’s dive into the details of caring for your Hoka, On and Brooks running shoes.

A handy and easy-to-follow tip is to regularly rotate between multiple pairs to evenly distribute the wear. In this way, your body and feet won’t get used to one pair of shoes. Switching shoes regularly will allow your body to adapt to different running styles.

Another useful tip is to dry your shoes after running. Sweat accumulates in the shoes and makes them wet. So, you should air dry the shoes overnight after each run. It will help retain the texture of the upper.

The cushioning of running shoes can also compress after regular use. To keep them soft and comfy, you can consider buying aftermarket insoles. These insoles also provide extra support while running.

For best performance, it is better to replace your running shoes after every 300-500 miles. This is the average lifespan of a regular running shoe. Therefore, you should replace your Hoka, On, and Brooks running shoes after this timespan. Some running shoes might show wear and tear before 300 miles. You can replace them earlier if it happens.

Hoka vs On Cloud vs Brooks for plantar fasciitis

What is Plantar Fasciitis

The shoes you use will depend on the type of plantar fasciitis you have. Hoka and Brooks shoes are good for severe plantar fasciitis. On Clouds have lightweight padding that suits runners with mild conditions. 

Runners with plantar fasciitis need more support under the foot. For this purpose, the cushioning of Hoka shoes can perform great. The maximal cushioning and support mechanisms of Hoka shoes are great for runners with severe plantar fasciitis. But, also remember that Hoka shoes have less arch support than On and Brooks.

On the other hand, On Clouds are cushioning and responsive shoes for running longer distances. They have moderate cushioning. Therefore, runners with mild plantar fasciitis can try these shoes.  

Some podiatrists also recommend Brooks shoes for plantar fasciitis. The GuideRails support is the best technology that helps provide support. Thus, you can get arch support with optimum cushioning. Both these features can help prevent plantar fasciitis pain.

Where are Hoka, On, and Brooks shoes manufactured?

Originally, Hoka was born in France. The company later started manufacturing in California and other states. The headquarters of the company expanded to different countries as well. Currently, the company manufactures shoes in three countries. These countries are Cambodia, Vietnam, and China.

On started its operations in Switzerland. However, the company manufactures products in different states too. The company has its factories in China and Vietnam. However, most of the On running shoes come from Asia.

Like Hoka and On, most Brooks shoes are also manufactured in Vietnam and China.

How long do Hoka, On, and Brooks shoes typically last?

Hoka shoes have a slightly longer lifespan compared to other shoes. It is due to the maximal cushioning. In general, Hoka shoes last for about 400-600 miles.

On running shoes might have the same range as regular shoes. The research shows the shoes last for 350-400 miles.

Brooks claims that its running shoes will last for 300-500 miles under normal conditions. 

The life span of shoes will depend on their material and cushioning. Shoes with thick cushioning, like Hoka, tend to last longer as the cushioning can last. If your shoes have less padding, it will compress with time, and you might have to replace the shoes.

Conclusion

Hoka, On, and Brooks are well-established brands that deliver quality footwear. Choosing one among these three can be a bit difficult. In this case, you should consider your preference.

Hoka shoes are great for runners who value a soft and comfy feel while running. On running shoes are ideal for a bouncy and responsive feel. Brooks shoes work well with stability and support.

Apart from these, many features are common among these shoes. So, it’s better to step up your game of running shoes and try something new!

Leave a Comment